JEE Main 2023 · 10 April · evening · Single correct · +4 / −1

Young's moduli of the material of wires A and B are in the ratio of 1: 4, while its area of cross sections are in the ratio of 1: 3. If the same amount of load is applied to both the wires, the amount of elongation produced in the wires A and B will be in the ratio of
[Assume length of wires A and B are same]

  1. (a) 1 : 12
  2. (b) 1 : 36
  3. (c) 12 : 1
  4. (d) 36 : 1
Answer and solution

Answer (c) 12 : 1

Solution

Physics sir · 4 steps

Same load and same length, so elongation goes as 1/(YA): just flip the product of the two ratios.

  1. Elongation formula. Young's modulus is stress over strain, Y = (F/A)/(Δ L/L). Rearranging gives the elongation of a loaded wire.

    Δ L = FL/AY

  2. Take the ratio. F and L are the same for both wires, so they cancel. That leaves (Δ L_A)/(Δ L_B) = (A_B Y_B)/(A_A Y_A).
  3. Put in numbers. With Y_A : Y_B = 1 : 4 and A_A : A_B = 1 : 3, we get (Δ L_A)/(Δ L_B) = (3 × 4)/(1 × 1) = 12.
  4. So. The elongations of A and B are in the ratio 12 : 1, option (c). Wire A is both thinner and less stiff, so it stretches more.

The idea to keep. For the same load and length, Δ L ∝ 1/AY. A thinner, softer wire stretches more, so check that your ratio favours the weaker wire.

Answer from the NTA final answer key. Solution by PrepWiser.

Study Elasticity

Asked about 90 times in JEE Main since 2020. This question is from 2023.