JEE Main 2020 · 8 January · morning · Single correct · +4 / −1
The decreasing order of reactivity towards dehydrohalogenation (E₁) reaction of the following compounds is :
- (a) B > D > A > C
- (b) D > B > C > A
- (c) B > A > D > C
- (d) B > D > C > A
Answer and solution
Answer (b) D > B > C > A
Solution
Chemistry ma’am · 3 steps
In E1 the carbocation decides everything, so rank each chloride by how stable its cation is.
- Slow step. In an E1 reaction the C–Cl bond first breaks on its own to give a carbocation, and this is the slow step. A proton is lost from the next carbon only after that. So the more stable the carbocation, the faster the reaction.
Compound Carbocation formed Extra stabilisation Rank D, 3-chlorobut-1-ene 2° allylic, right next to the C=C resonance with the π bond, plus hyperconjugation 1 B, 4-chlorobut-1-ene 1° at first, then a 1,2-H shift gives the 2° allylic cation nearby π bond helps, and the shift leads to resonance 2 C, 2-chlorobutane 2° alkyl hyperconjugation only 3 A, 1-chlorobutane 1° alkyl very little 4 - Why B beats C. The double bond in B is two carbons away from the cationic carbon. It helps that carbon lose Cl⁻, and a 1,2-hydride shift then turns the cation into the resonance-stabilised 2° allylic one. B still ranks below D, because D reaches that allylic cation directly without any primary stage.
- So. The decreasing order of E1 reactivity is D > B > C > A, which is option (b).
The idea to keep. For any E1 or S_N1 ranking, first draw the carbocation each substrate gives. Allylic resonance beats plain alkyl groups. Also check whether a hydride shift can turn a poor cation into a better one.
Answer from the NTA final answer key. Solution by PrepWiser.