JEE Main 2023 · 11 April · evening · Single correct · +4 / −1
Compound from the following that will not produce precipitate on reaction with AgNO₃ is :
- (a)
- (b)
- (c)
- (d)
Answer and solution
Answer (b)
Solution
Chemistry ma’am · 3 steps
Silver nitrate pulls off bromide only if the carbocation left behind is stable, so judge each cation.
- What AgNO3 needs. Ag⁺ takes away Br⁻ as a pale yellow AgBr precipitate. That only happens if the C–Br bond can break to give a carbocation, so the more stable the cation, the faster the precipitate.
R-Br + Ag⁺ → R⁺ + AgBr v
Option Where Br sits Cation after losing Br⁻ AgBr precipitate? (a) Ph-CH=CH-CH₂Br allylic sp³ carbon allylic, conjugated with the ring, resonance stabilised yes (b) 1-bromocyclohexene vinylic sp² carbon vinyl cation, very unstable no (c) Ph-CH₂Br benzylic sp³ carbon benzyl, resonance stabilised yes (d) 3-bromocyclopropene ring sp³ carbon cyclopropenyl, aromatic (2π electrons) yes, very fast - Why vinylic fails. In 1-bromocyclohexene, Br sits on a double-bonded carbon. Resonance with the C=C gives the C–Br bond partial double bond character, and the vinyl cation it would form is very unstable, so the bond does not ionise.
- So. Only (b), the vinylic bromide, gives no precipitate with AgNO₃.
The idea to keep. For AgNO₃ tests, ask what carbocation forms when the halide leaves. Allylic, benzylic or aromatic cations precipitate fast; vinylic and aryl halides do not react.
Answer from the NTA final answer key. Solution by PrepWiser.