JEE Main 2023 · 11 April · evening · Single correct · +4 / −1

Compound from the following that will not produce precipitate on reaction with AgNO₃ is :

  1. (a)
    Option (a)
  2. (b)
    Option (b)
  3. (c)
    Option (c)
  4. (d)
    Option (d)
Answer and solution

Answer (b)

Solution

Chemistry ma’am · 3 steps

Silver nitrate pulls off bromide only if the carbocation left behind is stable, so judge each cation.

  1. What AgNO3 needs. Ag⁺ takes away Br⁻ as a pale yellow AgBr precipitate. That only happens if the C–Br bond can break to give a carbocation, so the more stable the cation, the faster the precipitate.

    R-Br + Ag⁺ → R⁺ + AgBr v

    OptionWhere Br sitsCation after losing Br⁻AgBr precipitate?
    (a) Ph-CH=CH-CH₂Brallylic sp³ carbonallylic, conjugated with the ring, resonance stabilisedyes
    (b) 1-bromocyclohexenevinylic sp² carbonvinyl cation, very unstableno
    (c) Ph-CH₂Brbenzylic sp³ carbonbenzyl, resonance stabilisedyes
    (d) 3-bromocyclopropenering sp³ carboncyclopropenyl, aromatic (2π electrons)yes, very fast
  2. Why vinylic fails. In 1-bromocyclohexene, Br sits on a double-bonded carbon. Resonance with the C=C gives the C–Br bond partial double bond character, and the vinyl cation it would form is very unstable, so the bond does not ionise.
  3. So. Only (b), the vinylic bromide, gives no precipitate with AgNO₃.

The idea to keep. For AgNO₃ tests, ask what carbocation forms when the halide leaves. Allylic, benzylic or aromatic cations precipitate fast; vinylic and aryl halides do not react.

Answer from the NTA final answer key. Solution by PrepWiser.

Study Qualitative Analysis — Salt Analysis

Asked about 80 times in JEE Main since 2020. This question is from 2023.