JEE Main 2023 · 8 April · morning · Single correct · +4 / −1
For a nucleus _A^A X having mass number A and atomic number Z
A. The surface energy per nucleon (bₛ)=-a₁ A^(2 / 3).
B. The Coulomb contribution to the binding energy b_c=-a₂ Z(Z-1)/A^(4 / 3)
C. The volume energy bᵥ=a₃ A
D. Decrease in the binding energy is proportional to surface area.
E. While estimating the surface energy, it is assumed that each nucleon interacts with 12 nucleons. ( a₁, a₂ and a₃ are constants)
Choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below:
- (a) C, D only
- (b) B, C, E only
- (c) B, C only
- (d) A, B, C, D only
Answer and solution
Answer (a) C, D only
Solution
Physics sir · 3 steps
Check each term against the liquid drop formula and watch which ones are per nucleon and which are totals.
- The model. The liquid drop model builds the binding energy from a few terms. The volume term adds to it. The surface and Coulomb terms subtract from it.
B = a₃ A - a₁ A^(2/3) - a₂ Z(Z-1)/A^(1/3)
- Where each comes from. Volume: every nucleon bonds only with its near neighbours, so B ∝ A. Surface: nucleons on the surface have fewer neighbours, and this loss scales with the area 4π R² ∝ A^(2/3). Coulomb: Z(Z-1)/2 proton pairs repel, with energy ∝ 1/R ∝ A^(-1/3).
Statement Correct form Verdict A: surface energy per nucleon = -a₁ A^(2/3) -a₁ A^(2/3) is the total. Per nucleon it is -a₁ A^(-1/3) false B: Coulomb term = -a₂ Z(Z-1)/A^(4/3) -a₂ Z(Z-1)/A^(1/3), because R ∝ A^(1/3) false C: volume energy = a₃ A a₃ A true D: decrease ∝ surface area ∝ 4π R² ∝ A^(2/3) true E: each nucleon has 12 partners Surface nucleons have fewer neighbours than interior ones false - So. If every nucleon had the full set of neighbours, there would be no surface term at all, so E fails. Only C and D are correct, which is option (a).
The idea to keep. Write each term from geometry: volume ∝ A, surface ∝ R² ∝ A^(2/3), Coulomb ∝ Z(Z-1)/R ∝ Z(Z-1)/A^(1/3). Then divide by A only if the question says per nucleon.
Answer from the NTA final answer key. Solution by PrepWiser.