JEE Main 2020 · 2 September · morning · Single correct · +4 / −1

If AB₄ molecule is a polar molecule, a possible geometry of AB₄ is

  1. (a) Tetrahedral
  2. (b) see-saw
  3. (c) Square pyramidal
  4. (d) Square planar
Answer and solution

Answer (b) see-saw

Solution

Chemistry ma’am · 3 steps

Match each shape to its lone pairs; only a lone pair that breaks the symmetry leaves a net dipole.

  1. What polar needs. Four identical A–B bond dipoles cancel only when they are arranged symmetrically around A. A polar AB₄ needs a shape where they cannot cancel.
    GeometryVSEPR typeExampleDipoles cancel?
    TetrahedralAB₄, no lone pairCH₄yes, non-polar
    See-sawAB₄E, 1 lone pairSF₄no, polar
    Square pyramidalAB₅E, 1 lone pairBrF₅needs 5 B atoms, not an AB₄ shape
    Square planarAB₄E₂, 2 lone pairsXeF₄yes, non-polar
  2. Why see-saw. In see-saw, the lone pair sits in an equatorial position of the trigonal bipyramid. The four bonds are no longer symmetric, so their dipoles add up to a net dipole moment.
  3. So. A polar AB₄ molecule can be see-saw, option (b), like SF₄.

The idea to keep. Identical bonds placed symmetrically (tetrahedral, square planar, linear, trigonal planar, octahedral) give zero dipole. A lone pair that spoils the symmetry, as in see-saw, makes it polar.

Answer from the NTA final answer key. Solution by PrepWiser.

Study Chemical Bonding & Molecular Structure

Asked about 210 times in JEE Main since 2020. This question is from 2020.